The Two-Edged Sword of Developing High-Potential Employees

March 27, 2025

Most companies make it a priority to invest in high-potential employees - the rising stars who promise innovation, leadership, and transformative potential. Companies pour resources into nurturing their most promising professionals, simultaneously creating value and vulnerability. This delicate balance reveals a critical challenge that's reshaping how organizations approach their rising stars.

The Sharp Edge of Investment

Organizations invest heavily in top talent, spending an average of 1-3% of their total salary budget on learning and development. Large enterprises dedicate up to 5% of their compensation budget to these promising professionals, seeing them as the cutting edge of future leadership. Each investment is a carefully honed blade, meant to carve out competitive advantage.

But every sharp edge has its risks.

The Cutting Backside of Retention

Despite the companies' desires, high-potential employees voluntarily leave their organizations for a variety of reasons, cutting through the organization's investment and leaving a wound that's costly to heal. Replacing a high-potential mid-to-senior level employee can cost between $100,000 and $300,000—a price that includes recruitment, onboarding, and the intangible loss of institutional knowledge.

What Drives the Cutting Edge?

Top talent seeks more than just a paycheck. They want:

  • Meaningful career development opportunities  
  • Challenging and engaging work
  • Recognition from leadership
  • A sense of purpose
  • Work-life balance that supports their professional growth

Organizations that fail to provide these elements find their talent wielding their skills as a weapon against the very companies that sharpened them.  

Balancing the Blade

This isn't just an HR challenge—it's a strategic imperative. Companies must learn to balance the two-edged nature of talent development, understanding that their investment can either strengthen their competitive edge or become the very instrument of their potential loss. Visionary leaders invest in tools like the tru® platform to ensure their investments are sound, aligning personal aspirations with organizational objectives.

Through a guided self-discovery journey, the tru platform reveals each person’s Achievement DNA – the roles, values, needs, and skills that are most energizing and satisfying – and Environment Insights to help understand what best supports truSelf expression. Armed with this information, managers and leaders can adjust development plans to remain in harmony with individual desires.  

Navigating the Razor's Edge

Successful organizations take a multi-faceted approach to investing in high-potential employees. Best practices center on personalized development plans that include:  

  • Transparent career progression pathways
  • Mentorship programs that provide real guidance
  • Flexible work arrangements
  • Continuous feedback and meaningful recognition

The tru platform offers My Path Forward to maintain mutual visibility and accountability between the individual and leadership to ensure continuous progress is made. The tru-Up Survey monitors the level to which each person is expressing their truSelf on the job, creating a mechanism to surface misalignment or detect when an employee may be looking to leave.  

The future belongs to companies that can transform their high-potential employee investment from a potentially damaging blade to a precision instrument of growth. In the razor-sharp world of talent management, the most successful organizations learn to wield their two-edged sword with remarkable skill and precision.

Are you ready to master the balance?

Back to other articles